*

*
UC Sports
Bill Koch offers the latest on the Cincinnati Bearcats


Bill Koch is a sportswriter covering the University of Cincinnati's athletics.

Powered by Blogger

Friday, March 07, 2008

Mauk update

Ben Mauk is taking one more shot at securing another year of eligibility to play football at the University of Cincinnati.
UC coach Brian Kelly said Friday that Mauk has provided the school with additional information regarding an injury he suffered before he enrolled at Wake Forest in 2003 that precluded him from playing for the Demon Deacons during his true freshman year.
Mauk was redshirted as a freshman at Wake. He enrolled at UC as a graduate student last year and became the Bearcats’ starting quarterback after injuries to his arm and his shoulder wiped out all but one game of his junior year at Wake Forest.
But the NCAA ruled on Feb. 12 that Mauk was not entitled to a sixth year in which to complete his five years of eligibility because his redshirt year as a freshman was not the result of an injury, but a decision by the school to have him sit out.
Now Mauk apparently is claiming that an injury would have prevented him from playing to his full potential that year anyway.
“He’s essentially including some additional information to the original information he sent out,” Kelly said, “that going into his first year at Wake he had a screw put in his foot. He’s got medical documentation. We’re submitting it on his behalf and we’ll see where it takes him.”
Mike Mauk, Ben’s father and high school coach at Kenton (Ohio) High School, confirmed Friday that he and Ben had provided UC with additional information, but would not go into specifics.
“We’re going to wait and see what they say,” Mike Mauk said. “I don’t know that I want to say everything right now.”
Kelly said the school plans to submit the new information to the NCAA within the next few days.
“We’re waiting for some additional medical information from the surgeon that took care of Ben,” Kelly said.
Asked why Mauk didn’t submit this information as part of his original request for a hardship waiver, Kelly said, “I think Ben’s got some clarity in his own mind relative to what the NCAA was looking for. What they were looking for was two separate seasons where he was affected by an injury.
“It put his attention now on, OK, well in 2003 I was redshirted., but here’s the deal. I couldn’t be the quarterback I wanted to be in the spread offense. He’s claiming, and he’s got medical documentation to back it up, that after track season, they put a screw in his foot.”
Mauk’s claim could be hurt by a comment he made last month after he learned that his hardship waiver had been denied, when he told reporters it wasn’t his idea to redshirt as a freshman.
“I thought I could help the team out,” he said, “and I wasn’t allowed to play, so I thought it was out of my control.”


11 Comments:

at 7:17 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

If the NCAA OK's this one, pigs will fly.

 
at 8:48 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Out of appreciation for Mauk's contribution to UC's excellect 2007 FB season, UC will forward the information that Ben has requested. But as a fan I don't see the NCAA changing their mind because Mauk wants to prosecute another legal strategy on the same matter already thoroughly reviewed.

It's like the legal principle of "double jeapardy". You only get one bite at the apple.

 
at 9:24 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

"Mauk’s claim could be hurt by a comment he made last month after he learned that his hardship waiver had been denied, when he told reporters it wasn’t his idea to redshirt as a freshman."

Goes to show what I've felt for a long time now. What you say can and will be used against you - and not just in a quart of law! And anything the NCAA can use against UC, it seems that they do and will.

 
at 12:59 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

At some point in life a person must move on. Go out to the pasture Ben.

 
at 6:55 AM Blogger zadoc said...

There's a fine line between tenacity and desperation. I think Ben has crossed over.

 
at 9:55 AM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Put Mauk out to pasture, really? We are not talking about Brett Favre here; Mauk is not a middle-aged man past his prime. He had an amazing season last year, why not let him shine for one more?

 
at 12:01 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mauk, your time is up, stop crying and move on. Bottom line.

 
at 12:15 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Mauks time is up here, people need to get over it and move on.

 
at 12:20 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

whoa, whoa...settle down here...a lot of people want the kid to move on in life...however, after talking to him, this is how he feels...coach kelly took a chance on him last year by offering him a scholarship when he couldn't even throw a football...ben feels that he should pursue every avenue possible to come back and give coach kelly and uc another season...he's ready to move on, but at the same time, if there's an opportunity to come back and play for uc, why not go for it? what is the worst that could happen? as far as his comments hurting this appeal, they don't at all...they actually help...ben chose to go to wake forest because there was a legitimate chance to play as a true freshman...ben traveled with the team, unlike the other freshmen, and practiced with the varsity...for some reason, he was not put in the games...he believes he was not played because the surgery on his toe would not allow him to use all his abilities to show the coaches he was ready...let's think about it...he's not a drop back qb...he can be, but he likes to run and make plays...look at wake forest's offense...the qb must be able to move around and cut and run the ball..these are his strengths and coming off a fresh surgery limited him...why would coach grobe play ben that year when the season started off poorly and there was a long shot to make a bowl game? obviously it would have been a waste...so in fact, ben wanting to play and help the team and not be redshirted helps his case because it shows he did everything he could to get on the field, but the coaches wouldn't play him..this, what ben is saying, is because his toe limited his abilities at that time...however, in the spring, when he was finally 100% healthy, he earned the coaches respect and took the starting job the next season from the same guy that played the year before...obviously ben was better then the guy that played over him his redshirt year, but the coaches wanted him to be able to make the proper cuts and be able to move around...he could not do this until the spring...ben did not provide this information the first time because he did not feel that the redshirt year was the year in question...this is backed up because the ncaa, after 2 weeks of reviewing the case, requested more information about the year he was hurt-asking his doctor whether or not he could have come back and played...so yeah, if ben is denied again, then he's ready to move on, but why not pursue every option to come back and play for the type of coach he hasn't had for a while and play for a city and state he loves and takes pride in? i feel ben's case now has precedent, and he will be back next season...everyone, i feel, is ready for the demetrius jones show, but mauk is the guy you want in shotgun next season...oh, and why wasn't this information a factor the first time? yeah, ben thought the only year in question was his broken arm/shoulder year...we all know how tough he is from what he has come back from..ben obviously wasn't going to complain and sit out his true freshman year because his toe bothered him...come on...wake was a place that he felt he could play as a true freshman, so why would he sit out when he made the travel roster and practiced with the varsity? this was his dream, to play division 1 football against the florida state's of college football...however, looking back, his toe surgery (big toe-a big toe we all need for balance and to push off of) kept him from playing that season...2 years of health problems keep him out=6th year...and his doctor that did the toe surgery is backing him up by writing a detailed letter...has anyone ever seen his toes and his ankle? titanium plate and 7 screws in his leg (broken tibula and fibula)..reconstructive nerve surgery down the inside of his ankle...the toes all have 2 major tendons...one in each toe was cut and the big toe had a titanium screw put in place (hammer toes)...ben cannot bend any of his left toes...the screw in his big toe was removed after his senior track year...try to run and cut on a big toe that has a hollow calcium build up in it...he was on crutches and limited in his training before arriving to wake...when he got there he wasn't 100% healthy...give him another year and watch BK hoist the crystal ball next season!

 
at 12:25 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

at 12:59 Anonymous said...
"At some point in life a person must move on. Go out to the pasture Ben."

Very well said - by a osu or xavier fan!

 
at 2:31 PM Anonymous Anonymous said...

Anon 12:20. Maybe UC should hire you to present Mauk's case to the NCAA.

Well put. With that kind of presentation, you could probably get Charles Williams reinstated for another year of basketball.

 
Post a Comment*

* Our online blogs currently are hosted and operated by a third party, namely, Blogger.com. You are now leaving the Cincinnati.Com website and will be linked to Blogger.com's registration page. The Blogger.com site and its associated services are not controlled by Cincinnati.Com and different terms of use and privacy policy will apply to your use of the Blogger.com site and services.

By proceeding and/or registering with Blogger.com you agree and understand that Cincinnati.Com is not responsible for the Blogger.com site you are about to access or for any service you may use while on the Blogger.com site.

<< Home


Blogs
Jim Borgman
Today at the Forum
Paul Daugherty
Politics Extra
N. Ky. Politics
Pop culture review
Cincytainment
Who's News
Television
Roller Derby Diva
Art
CinStages Buzz....
The Foodie Report
cincyMOMS
Classical music
John Fay's Reds Insider
Bengals
High school sports
NCAA
UC Sports
CiN Weekly staff
Soundcheck

Advertisement